pizza bg

Best pizza: The search for the best Long Island pie

LikeTweetSharePinEmail

Our critics selected 32 of their favorite LI pizzas, which battled it out, bracket-style. You voted, the pairings shrunk, and a winner reigned supreme.

Congrats to PRINCE UMBERTO’S and its potato-egg pizza for capturing the popular vote!

restaurant image

Also, a big round of applause for all 32 delicious pizzas. Scroll down to see the results of all five rounds of voting.

FINAL RESULTS
Time left to vote:

0%0 VOTES

massas VOTE

Pizza No. 3

Massa's

80 Gerard St.

Huntington

631-923-3473

Pizza No. 3 is the star at Massa's. It's topped with fresh mozzarella, scallions, pancetta, scamorza cheese and truffle oil.
WEBSITE MAP IT YELP

More
VS

0%0 VOTES

princeumbertos VOTE

Potato egg

Prince Umberto's

721D Franklin Ave.

Franklin Square

516-872-9049

Prince Umberto's potato-and-egg pie is suitable for breakfast, lunch or dinner, with a topping similar to a creamy omelet that's capped with perfectly cooked slices of well-seasoned potato.
WEBSITE MAP IT YELP

More

share my vote

ROUND 1 RESULTS ROUND 2 RESULTS ROUND 3 RESULTS ROUND 4 RESULTS

Credits

Comments